Friday, December 21, 2007

A New Approach

I'm trying something new when it comes to studying and understanding the Bible. When people ask questions, I'm attempting to jettison my preconceived notions and entertain multiple possibilities while honestly assessing the text in its context, its relation to the rest of scripture, and as many nuances of the original language as I am capable of examining. I like it. I figure once I've done the legwork, I go ask my pastor what his stance on it, and let him show me a million more little things that prove me wrong and give me a clearer understanding of how to study scripture.

Of course, people on forums don't do this -- they just sort of spout off whatever their leaders tell them and refuse to critically examine anything. It's frustrating because I don't want to be That Guy who is belligerent about his beliefs, but I feel like I have a responsibility to make sure people actually care about their professed beliefs.

I should probably just quit forums. They're always a cesspool.

Sunday, December 16, 2007

Judging

I wrote you in my letter not to associate with immoral people; I did not at all mean with the immoral people of the world, or with the covetous and swindlers, or with idolaters, for then you would have to go out of the world. But actually, I wrote to you not to associate with any so-called brother if he is an immoral person, or covetous, or an idolater, or a reviler, or a drunkard, or a swindler -- not even to eat with such a one. For what have I to do with judging outsiders? Do you not judge those who are within the church? But those who are outside, God judges. Remove the wicked man from among yourselves.
-1 Corinthians 5:9-13

Last night, my wife and I caught part of a special on CNN called "God's Warriors" or something. It focused on the "culture war" that the religious right is currently engaged in. I didn't watch much -- having been a part of those kinds of churches in the past, I don't require a television special to introduce me to that world. But what I did see really got me thinking about the passage above, and I realized there are a lot of Christians whose priorities are depressingly misaligned.

First off, we have this issue of associating with immoral people. There is a huge movement in the church to put kids in Christian schools or to homeschool them. While there are good reasons for this, the one that seems most popular is the desire to isolate the kids -- someone actually used the word "bubble" on the program last night. Parents want to keep their kids away from worldly influences, to keep them "safe." The problem is that, in remaining in a perpetually Christian environment, the kids will eventually run into the "immoral people" that Paul warns against.

I went to a Christian high school, and I spent many years in youth groups. My non-Christian friends always respected my beliefs. Sure, they'd say "aw, come on!" if I declined an offer to get drunk, but there was never any pressure to be the same. There was (and still is) an understanding that we approach the world from two different frameworks that will sometimes prevent us from engaging in the same behavior.

On the other hand, when I was with the churchy kids, everything they did seemed more acceptable. These were people with the same views as me, so what they do must be acceptable, even good to do! It's what we call peer pressure, and the level of pressure is directly proportional to the number of things the peers in question have in common.

This is backwards! Paul explicitly says that the people to avoid are the people in our Christian communities who engage in immoral behavior. There is no problem with hanging out with people of differing religious views -- the problem is with the "so-called brothers" who behave the way immoral non-brothers behave.

We're supposed to be judging those people, not the ones outside of the church... and we do exactly the opposite. We don't judge when our pastors get caught sleeping with the organ lady or buying meth, but we judge all the non-Christians by seeking to change the country's laws to make their actions illegal. Why? Why do we perpetuate this fake culture war? The Bible never commands us to, and we are clearly ignoring the stuff that is actually in there.

I think it has to do with the obsession with attendance numbers. Churches are only considered "successful" if the number of attendees is going up -- and they're "failures" if that number drops. It's not about teaching people how to be Christlike, but maintaining the member list. It's ridiculous. It's this kind of attitude that creates entire congregations of "immoral people" -- people who drive like jerks, cheat on their taxes, and gossip about everyone else in the congregation. These people become indignant when faced with correction and refuse to submit to any kind of biblical authority. But that's fine -- they're paying the bills and making the church swell with numbers. Awesome.

Sunday, December 09, 2007

Contradictions in the Bible

The subject of inerrancy pops up occasionally in a few blogs that I read, and it's been on my mind for a while, so I figured I may as well blog about it.

The general idea of inerrancy, it seems, is "The Bible is always literally, factually true." I guess there are different degrees of "inerrancy," and I've heard my description referred to as "fundamentalist inerrancy," but I'm not sure that it matters for the purposes of this blog.

I can't get behind a statement that says "The Bible is always literally, factually true" because the Bible contains many different styles of writing -- some is poetic, some is historical, some is allegorical, and some is written in code and is kind of talking about something else. However, the arguments I've read against inerrancy are pretty weak and point to pretty shallow theology and a lazy approach to scripture, as well as a lack of interest in history.

There are certain things that ancient Jews would read differently than we do today. Numbers are a big one -- if a passage says "400 men marched," it doesn't mean that there were actually 400 men. It means there might have been 400, maybe 320, maybe 450...but the number 400 is significant (I don't want to get into numerology tonight). If an objection to inerrancy involves numbers, it is probably irrelevant.

Names and genealogies are also different from a biblical perspective than from an American one. In the Bible, a person's name speaks about that person's nature, and sometimes what kind of background they have. The name means something and affects the meaning of the passage (for example, "Jabez" means "sorrow," making a certain book a waste of ink and paper). Genealogies, being a collection of names, talk about the kind of background a person can have. They are not meant to be considered exhaustive. Ever. They cover the important stuff. Heck, Jabez completely breaks continuity when he shows up. That's not considered weird to the original readers of the scriptures. If an objection to inerrancy involves names or genealogies, it is probably irrelevant.

I've heard claims that there are theological contradictions. Dealing with any specific contradiction will require 1) finding an example, since I didn't commit them to memory, and 2) pointing out all of the different words in the "contradictory" passages that provide a more nuanced understanding than what we get in "plain English." I don't feel like doing these, but I will say that a look at the Hebrew or Greek, along with some historical context, will (probably) clear things up.

As I said, I don't believe in inerrancy (as I understand the term), but I think several of the reasons offered for not believing in it are irrelevant.