Sunday, December 09, 2007

Contradictions in the Bible

The subject of inerrancy pops up occasionally in a few blogs that I read, and it's been on my mind for a while, so I figured I may as well blog about it.

The general idea of inerrancy, it seems, is "The Bible is always literally, factually true." I guess there are different degrees of "inerrancy," and I've heard my description referred to as "fundamentalist inerrancy," but I'm not sure that it matters for the purposes of this blog.

I can't get behind a statement that says "The Bible is always literally, factually true" because the Bible contains many different styles of writing -- some is poetic, some is historical, some is allegorical, and some is written in code and is kind of talking about something else. However, the arguments I've read against inerrancy are pretty weak and point to pretty shallow theology and a lazy approach to scripture, as well as a lack of interest in history.

There are certain things that ancient Jews would read differently than we do today. Numbers are a big one -- if a passage says "400 men marched," it doesn't mean that there were actually 400 men. It means there might have been 400, maybe 320, maybe 450...but the number 400 is significant (I don't want to get into numerology tonight). If an objection to inerrancy involves numbers, it is probably irrelevant.

Names and genealogies are also different from a biblical perspective than from an American one. In the Bible, a person's name speaks about that person's nature, and sometimes what kind of background they have. The name means something and affects the meaning of the passage (for example, "Jabez" means "sorrow," making a certain book a waste of ink and paper). Genealogies, being a collection of names, talk about the kind of background a person can have. They are not meant to be considered exhaustive. Ever. They cover the important stuff. Heck, Jabez completely breaks continuity when he shows up. That's not considered weird to the original readers of the scriptures. If an objection to inerrancy involves names or genealogies, it is probably irrelevant.

I've heard claims that there are theological contradictions. Dealing with any specific contradiction will require 1) finding an example, since I didn't commit them to memory, and 2) pointing out all of the different words in the "contradictory" passages that provide a more nuanced understanding than what we get in "plain English." I don't feel like doing these, but I will say that a look at the Hebrew or Greek, along with some historical context, will (probably) clear things up.

As I said, I don't believe in inerrancy (as I understand the term), but I think several of the reasons offered for not believing in it are irrelevant.