Saturday, September 08, 2007

Free Will

First off, I'd like to echo Bill Nye by saying "Science rules!" With that out of the way, I'm going to complain.

In the last few weeks of my career at UofM Flint, the biology department clipped an article about the way humans make decisions and put it up on their corkboard in the hall of MSB. The main assertion of the article? "Humans don't have free will." The whole article was trying to make the claim that humans are not free agents because -- and here's the best part -- because we make decisions based on factors like our past experience, our body of knowledge, and what seems most beneficial and correct. That's right, we don't have free will because we always have a reason for acting the way that we do.

The problem, of course, is that there is more than one definition of "free will." The definition they use is the one that says man is a free agent, so that for every decision we make, it is equally plausible that we could have made the opposite decision. This means that when I wake up in the morning, I can roll over and put my arm around my wife, or I could roll over and punch her in the face. I have free will, therefore I'm capable of either! The problem with this definition, of course, is that I love my wife and would never intentionally hurt her -- there is a higher choice that I have made that overrides choices like whether I will hug my wife or hit her. Of course, if I use this definition of free will, the decision-hierarchy proves that I don't actually have it.

There is another definition of "free will" that I think captures the essence of the phrase -- having free will means that God doesn't stop you from acting. The main reason I like this definition is because it stays true to the context in which the term was first required, namely a context where the existence of God was assumed and the issue was why humans are capable of acting in ways that anger him. Having free will doesn't mean I'm going to haul off and smack my wife, but it does explain why I'm capable of arguing with her about the stupidest things and saying hurtful things -- because God doesn't plug in and make me settle down. 

My problem with that article was that it extracted the notion of free will from a theistic context and proceeded to make arguments against it. But outside of a theistic context, the discussion of free will is moot! If there is no God who can potentially make you act contrary to your wishes, then "free will" is a hollow phrase. The fact that our decisions are not completely random is not an argument against free will, just evidence of the complexity and sophistication of the human brain. It is not a theological argument.

No comments: