Showing posts with label purpose driven. Show all posts
Showing posts with label purpose driven. Show all posts

Friday, October 19, 2007

PDL #4

Nothing new to report, honestly. Rick Warren has no clue what goes on in the afterlife, since he says "There are two options: heaven or hell" and says that is based on "What you do with Jesus" on this earth... but then he goes on to say that everything we do in this life affects the next. Which is it? Two options? Or more options?

The Bible spends quite a bit of time talking about the earth being remade and God bringing a new city to the earth (see the last couple chapters of Revelation). Many of Jesus' parables refer to "the kingdom of heaven" -- that's the city, and contrary to the simplistic teachings of most churches, that is not where all Christians end up. Most of us will end up in the kingoms of the earth, ruled by Christians who get to enter the city and come back with branches from the tree of life (see Revelation, most of Jesus' parables).

But yeah, we kind of forgot to do day 5...but I'm not sure I can keep this daily thing going. I'm not sure how many times I need to say "This book is shallow and heretical."

Wednesday, October 17, 2007

Purpose-driven Life, day 3 review

I neglected something from yesterday's reading: The chapter ended with a trite poem whose rhythm took a vacation. It was horrible. And also longer than all of the scripture verses he used, combined...

Anyway, Day 3. I don't have my notes with me right now, but I remember he managed to screw up half of a Proverb. His translation said something like, "Simple living is the way to go!", where my NASB says (roughly), "He who makes himself poor is wealthy." Huge difference.

Also, despite his claim that his book is not a self-help book, his book is a self-help book. He says "It's not about you," but everything he covers is about "you" and "your" purpose. I've looked up his verses, and none of them, taken in context, have anything to do with "your" purpose -- it's always God's purpose.

Monday, October 15, 2007

Purpose-Driven Life, day 2 review

Okay, we just finished the reading for day 2, and it's more of the same. Not only is he relying on The Message for everything, he's finding the most inaccurately translated bits and using those as the basis for... logically disconnected thoughts. He goes from verses that (in their actual context) talk about God ordaining the times and borders of the nations and says that God chooses everyone's hair and eye colors. How do you get there? I don't doubt that God can, but I don't see a reason to believe that he does. 

The most annoying thing today is that he likes to take half of a verse and build something on it. That really irks me. Bringing up a single verse is bad enough -- you need the entire surrounding passage as well as a general understanding of the book, to understand what a verse really means. If you take a piece of a verse and start applying it to stuff, you get wrong ideas. It's a pretty simple concept. The Bible is not a collection of proverbs (only one book of the Bible is), so a person cannot treat each verse as an isolated idea and expect to come away with right understanding.

Purpose-Driven Life, day 1 review

My wife and I have been attending a small group for couples for a few months. The group is affiliated with our friends' church, and we're the only people who don't attend that church. The group is now going through The Purpose-Driven Life because the church is doing "40 Days of Purpose."

I doubt there are people out there who aren't familiar with this book, but just in case I'll sum it up: It's a Christian self-help book. It became very popular very quickly because it claimed not to be a self-help book, and it says lots of things that make people feel warm and squishy inside. Back when it came out, I flipped through it to see what all the hoopla was about, and thought it was pretty shallow.

Anyway, once we heard we were doing this book, I wasn't pleased, but I thought, "Ok, fine, we'll do it and I'll try not to be too big of a jerk about it." That's going to be a challenge.

We read through the first chapter last night and looked up all of the scripture references that were in there. Most of them were taken from The Message, which is a paraphrase of the Bible (when you paraphrase something, you try and put it in your own words), which means it's not meant for the same kind of study as a translation, so already the book is not sitting well with me. What was most disappointing, though, was the fact that almost every single verse was taken grossly out of context.

For example, he points to Colossians 1:16 as the basis for the chapter - it says that all things were created by God and find their purpose in him. That's cute and all, but when I looked the verse up in my NASB, it said that all things were created by God and for God. The difference should be self-evident, but I'll state it anyway: It does not say anything about finding your purpose in God. The verse is part of a bigger passage that talks about the redemptive work of Christ -- the focus is completely on God, not on us!

And that's the story of every scripture reference in the chapter - he finds a verse in The Message that says something about "purpose" and runs with it, regardless of what the surrounding passage is talking about. And then, of course, people eat it up because we want a greater purpose than obeying God's commands.